Comparative chart

Comparing dialysis options

There are different benefits and considerations for PD and ICHD. Please remember that every patient differs in terms of age, medical condition, physical condition, and lifestyle choices. It's best to discuss medical and lifestyle considerations with your healthcare team so you understand all the treatment options and how they might impact you. Below is a quick comparative chart for different types of dialysis.

Type of dialysis Benefits Some points to consider
PD
  • Fit your treatment around your lifestyle (e.g. flexibility for work, school, and other activities)
  • Portable and flexible - easy to take your therapy with you when you travel
  • Continuous therapy is gentler and more like your natural kidney function
  • Fewer visits to the dialysis unit for treatment
  • No needles
  • Independence - you typically perform your therapy yourself
  • Can do dialysis therapy while you sleep
  • Daily exchanges
  • Permanent access catheter
  • Storage space in your home
  • Potential feeling of fullness
ICHD
  • Regular contact with other hemodialysis patients and staff
  • 3 treatments per week
  • No need for keeping equipment/supplies at home
  • Immediate access to medical help during therapy
  • Travel to center/unit 3 times a week, on a fixed schedule for an average of 4 hours each treatment
  • Need for permanent access
  • Insertion of 2 needles for each treatment
  • Possible discomfort such as headache, nausea, leg cramps, tiredness